Why would you talk to a police officer who stopped you? There are several reasons. First, you feel like you have nothing to hide and you want to explain your way out of the situation. Second, you are confused by the Miranda warnings. This article is designed to help clarify Miranda in one key aspect — the invocation of your rights must be unequivocal. In other words, keep your answer simple.

Before I turn to the Miranda rule, I want to share something personal about the first reason. I sympathize with the first reason. Human beings naturally want to explain things. I have certainly felt the temptation when stopped by police officers. Avoid the temptation. Even if you are innocent or confident in your speaking ability, there is absolutely nothing to gain by talking with police.

You should always be polite to police officers, but keep this in mind. Police are allowed to lie to you and tell you that if you talk you won’t get into trouble. Remember only the prosecutors are authorized to make deals, not police officers.

Now, let’s talk about the Miranda rule as created by the United States Supreme Court in Miranda v. Arizona (1966) 384 U.S. 436. A typical Miranda warning is “ You have the right to remain silent. Anything you say can and will be used against you in a court of law. You have the right to have an attorney present during questioning. If you cannot afford an attorney, one will be appointed for you. Do you understand these rights? ” In border states, including Texas, New Mexico, Arizona, and California, suspects who are not United States citizens are given an additional warning “If you are not a United States citizen, you may contact your country’s consulate prior to any questioning.”

It may look clear cut, but there are a few things that are confusing about this warning even to a lawyer. First, when are police officers required to give the warning? The short answer is, only during a custodial interrogation. Custodial interrogation means that you are being questioned while you are in custody or you believe that in the surrounding environment you are not free to leave. Even if you are a lawyer, custodial interrogation is ambiguous.

This leads to next question, How can you protect yourself when you are stopped by a police officer? Luckily, the answer is simple. Invoke your rights, keep your answer simple and then keep quiet.

Keep your answer simple. Just say, “Officer I do not want to talk to you about anything.” “I want to talk to a lawyer now.” “I do not give my consent to any search.”

Assertion of your rights must be unambiguous. Davis v. United States (1994) 512 U.S. 452. If you are not clear and to the point, you ran the risk of waiving your rights. Consider the example of the Davis case. The defendant in Davis, said “Maybe I should talk to a lawyer.” The United States Supreme Court held that this answer was ambiguous and allowed the statements Davis made after this invocation of rights to be allowed into evidence.

You maybe asking, “So does that mean that I can say absolutely nothing to police officers?” The answer is NO.

First, of all, do not fail the attitude test. Always be polite to police officers to avoid tense situations. One of my law school professors always reminded his students about the dangers of getting too excited about constitutional liberties and ignoring the real world. In the real world, police officers have a tough job, and if you answer them in a disrespectful manner they will come down on you hard because you failed the attitude test.

Second, if a police officer stops you while you are walking, and asks you for identification, it is probably in your best interest to provide such information. If you are driving and you get pulled over, produce your license , registration and insurance information. Then tell police the magic words, (see keep your answer simple above), put your hands on the wheel and keep quiet.

Comments are closed.

Contact The Law Office Of Vincent W. Davis


Experienced Law Firm

Office Locations Where Can We Meet You?

Arcadia Office
150 N. Santa Anita Ave,
Suite 200
Arcadia, CA 91006
Phone: (626) 446-6442 Fax: (626)-446-6454
Get Directions
Beverly Hills Office
*Virtual Office
9465 Wilshire Blvd.
Suite 300
Beverly Hills, CA 90212
Phone: (310)-880-5733 Get Directions
La Mirada Office
*Virtual Office
Cerritos Towne Center
17777 Center Court Drive ,
Suite 600
Cerritos, California, 90703
Phone: 888-888-6542 Get Directions
Los Angeles Office
*Virtual Office
Gas Comdivany Tower
555 West Fifth Street,
31st Floor
Los Angeles, California, 90013
Phone: (213)-400-4132 Get Directions
Long Beach Office
*Virtual Office
Landmark Square
111 West Ocean Blvd.,
Suite 400
Long beach, California, 90802
Get Directions
Irvine Office
*Virtual Office
Oracle Tower
17901 Von Karman Avenue,
Suite 600
Irvine, California, 92614
Phone: (949)-203-3971 Fax: (949)-203-3972 Get Directions
Ontario Office
*Virtual Office
Lakeshore Center
3281 E. Guasti Road,
7th Floor
City of Ontario, California, 91761
Phone: (909)-996-5644 Get Directions
Riverside Office
*Virtual Office
Turner Riverwalk
11801 divierce Street,
Suite 200
Riverside, California, 92505
Phone: (909)-996-5644 Get Directions
San Diego
*Virtual Office
Emerald divlaza
402 West Broadway,
Suite #400
San Diego, California, 92101
Phone: (619)-885-2070 Get Directions
Aliso Viejo
*Virtual Office
Ladera Cordivorate Terrace
999 Cordivorate Drive,
Suite 100
Ladera Ranch, California, 92694
Phone: (714) 721-3822 Get Directions